I would like to see a thread started over in the New Finds section, where we can post suggestions, corrections, and finds that might be included. However I understand that mreaves53 hasn't been admitted to New Finds area yet?
Another issue though is the question of whether this list is to be public or private. Ie if it is public like Lyngsat, then things posted in New Finds, or things posted in the private areas over at Satforums shouldn't be put on the list. However if the list is made at least semi-private, ie perhaps protected by passwords only posted in the New Finds area (and the private areas at Satforums), then perhaps there wouldn't be a problem, or at least I don't anticipate a problem from those on the
Sadoun forums.... I suspect it would still be considered a problem for some at Satforums, but I think there are ways that it could be done within the
rules of both forums, ie if things are only listed by those who find the info, thus avoiding "re-posting".
However, while waiting for a thread in New Finds, I do have a couple questions. I was looking for example at the listing for AMC-11, and I can't figure out why the frequency colum is all messed up. Ie the frequencies don't seem to be correct (or at least they don't match what is in Lyngsat).
For example, Lyngsat shows transponders at 3980 and 3995. On this list, the 3980 transponder seems to show up at a variety of frequencies between 3980 and 3993. The 3995 transponder shows up here as a group of frequencies between 3995 and 4008. I'm not sure how this happened. It's almost as if there was an algolrithm used to generate the frequency, which added some interpolation value between that and the next frequency for each additional channel in the mux {just a wild guess}.
Also in one of the above examples, there is a so-called "FREE" DCII channels that is labled as DVB, when it is really a DCII "FP" signal, which are encrypted with a public key. Also, as mentioned in a private message, the VPID column is really the channel number (from vct) for DCII channels, and has nothing to do with video.
I also think there needs to be separate columns for the "HD" designation {and perhaps 4.2.2 could be included in this}, as it isn't possible to tell whether an
HD channel is DVB or DCII or whether it is encrypted or not. Also, a comment column might be useful, to include other important features about the channel that might affect our ability to view it.
Also, I notice that DTV and Dishnet sats are lumped together at 110/119, but the DTV satellite at 101 is not listed. I also notice that some other satellites are not listed for some reason.